Search Your Destination Now!

Kelleys Island Rentals

Rental Rates ($USD weekly)

Guests

Check Rates & Availability:

Update Results Reset Dates
Filter

Results: 47 Rentals

  • Screened in back porch is a haven!
    From $164 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Screened in back porch is a haven!

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    6

    Our cottage home is a family-oriented, non-smoking, 3 bedroom, 2 full bath ranch style home built in 2000. It will slee ...

    From $164 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Beautiful & Secluded, 3-Bedrooom, Solar-Powered Home on Kelleys Isl. with cart!
    From $412 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Beautiful & Secluded, 3-Bedrooom, Solar-Powered Home on Kelleys Isl. with cart!

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    10

    Quarry Vista Lodge is an all-electric solar-powered "Green" home located at 306 Lower Cliff Drive on Kelleys Island, Ohi ...

    From $412 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Conti's Cottage-Lake Views
    From $370 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Conti's Cottage-Lake Views

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    8

    Enjoy a comfortable large cottage for up to 8 people on Kelley's Island. Perfect for large and extended families to enjo ...

    From $370 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lakefront place for you
    From $400 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Lakefront place for you

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    8

    Just a short distance from the center of town, the South Shore Villa on Kelleys Island is the ideal spot for a weekend, ...

    From $400 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • The ideal Kelleys Island family vacation rental
    From $325 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    The ideal Kelleys Island family vacation rental

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    12

    Enjoy a relaxing week on Lake Erie's largest and most family-friendly island - Kelleys Island - the perfect getaway. L ...

    From $325 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Cedar Cottage - Kelleys Island (Lake Erie) Vacation Retreat
    From $325 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Cedar Cottage - Kelleys Island (Lake Erie) Vacation Retreat

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    The Cedar Cottage is the perfect place to stay for your getaway to Kelleys Island, Ohio. This beautiful newer 3-bedroom ...

    From $325 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Superb 4,000 sq\/ft Lake View
    From $450 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Superb 4,000 sq\/ft Lake View

    Bedrooms:
    5
    Bathrooms:
    7
    Sleeps:
    18

    Casa Del Sol is a 4,000 sq/ft, 7 bedroom 4.5 bath Cape Cod situated on the cul-de-sac on a private street with a view of ...

    From $450 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Summer Wind Lake House - Kelley's Island, OH
    From $440 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Summer Wind Lake House - Kelley's Island, OH

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    The Summer Wind Lake House is a 2 bedroom plus loft, 1.5 bath summer house that sleeps 8. Just down the lane from the be ...

    From $440 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Original Kelleys island cottage built in 1860, completely renovated!
    From $708 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Original Kelleys island cottage built in 1860, completely renovated!

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    5
    Sleeps:
    12

    Welcome to the ‘Wigwam’. This quaint cottage underwent a major renovation completed in 2021. Our interior designers cre ...

    From $708 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • The Old Nest Vacation Waterfront Home
    From $550 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    The Old Nest Vacation Waterfront Home

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    5
    Sleeps:
    10

    You deserve the comfort of a 5-bedroom home within walking distance from town. You deserve one of the largest porches o ...

    From $550 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • \Kelleys Island Escape\ is a short walk from downtown Kelleys Island & sleeps 6.
    From $275 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    \"Kelleys Island Escape\" is a short walk from downtown Kelleys Island & sleeps 6.

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    This 2-bedroom house has two full bathrooms; both with walk-in showers. The master bedroom has a queen-size bed. The s ...

    From $275 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Kelleys Island Luxury Home On Secluded Private Road
    From $325 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Kelleys Island Luxury Home On Secluded Private Road

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    10

    This brand new 2 story home completed in 2017 comes with 4 large bedrooms and 2 1/2 baths. An expansive first floor ope ...

    From $325 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Beautiful, newly renovated condo steps from the pool and downtown entertainment!
    From $250 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Beautiful, newly renovated condo steps from the pool and downtown entertainment!

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Weekly rentals Friday to Friday with a six night minimum during peak summer season. Gorgeous and newly renovated, Blue H ...

    From $250 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Relax at our Kelleys Island Home
    From $387 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Relax at our Kelleys Island Home

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    10

    Welcome to our relaxing home on Kelleys Island. Adjacent to the nature preserve, the house has scenic outdoor space to ...

    From $387 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • New Construction for 2023. Lake Home with Quarry Views.
    From $600 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    New Construction for 2023. Lake Home with Quarry Views.

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    10

    Beautiful 3 Bedroom, 2.5 Bath Home on a quiet street with Quarry Views from the backyard. Large yard with stamped concre ...

    From $600 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $157 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $157 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Cozy Island Chalet, Ideal Retreat for Kelleys Island Nature Lovers & Adventurers
    From $437 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Cozy Island Chalet, Ideal Retreat for Kelleys Island Nature Lovers & Adventurers

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    4

    Nestled on captivating Kelleys Island, this cozy island chalet beckons, a haven of peace and comfort awaiting weary trav ...

    From $437 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Perfect family home near downtown Kelleys Island
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Perfect family home near downtown Kelleys Island

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    Division Street Retreat is a great family rental located just north of downtown Kelleys Island. Our three bedroom, 2 bat ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Kelleys Island Luxury Lake Shack
    From $600 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Kelleys Island Luxury Lake Shack

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    7

    Experience Kelleys Island in comfort and style. The KI Lake Shack is a newly built 3bed/2bath, 1400sf ranch on a quiet ...

    From $600 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Marblehead Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $130 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Marblehead Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $130 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • ADA Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    ADA Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Marblehead Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $130 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Marblehead Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $130 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Marblehead Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $130 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Marblehead Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $130 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • ADA Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    ADA Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Vineyard Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $101 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Vineyard Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $101 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    6

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $137 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Marblehead Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $130 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Marblehead Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $130 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Vineyard Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $101 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Vineyard Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $101 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    3

    Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect su ...

    From $110 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Brand new vacation home, built 2022!  Great Location on Kelleys Island!
    From $331 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Brand new vacation home, built 2022! Great Location on Kelleys Island!

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    6

    This property is a custom 3 bed , 2 bath home built in 2022. Main floor has a great open floor plan, ready to host your ...

    From $331 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details