Search Your Destination Now!

White Area Rentals

Rental Rates ($USD weekly)

Guests

Check Rates & Availability:

Update Results Reset Dates
Filter

Results: 53 Rentals

  • Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!
    From $557 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    5
    Sleeps:
    10

    Beautiful lakefront rental house. 5 bedrooms an office, sleeps up to 10 or more comfortably. Perfect space for entertain ...

    From $557 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Family Friendly completely remodeled secluded vacation spot near Lake Shafer
    From $228 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Family Friendly completely remodeled secluded vacation spot near Lake Shafer

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    8

    This house was built in 1888 but was completely remodeled in 2016 to update all the amenities and to revive the beautifu ...

    From $228 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Gorgeous lake front cottage. Enjoy those summer nights on the lake
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Gorgeous lake front cottage. Enjoy those summer nights on the lake

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    Property has 3 bedrooms and one bath with brand new covered patio. Hotel quality mattresses and linens. Plenty of parkin ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Waterfront Lake Shafer - Hot Tub + Fireplace
    From $756 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Waterfront Lake Shafer - Hot Tub + Fireplace

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    5
    Sleeps:
    15

    Custom-designed lakefront home built for multi-family & multi-generational getaways. • Main house + attached in-law suit ...

    From $756 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!
    From $398 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    4

    ‘Cozy Cottage’ | Dog Friendly w/ Fee | 3-Season Room | Gas Grill | Fire Pit Make this 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom Monticello ...

    From $398 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Blue Door Cottages
    From $123 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Blue Door Cottages

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    2

    <p>While you're here, you can enjoy all the comforts of home and more, including free WiFi and a firepit, as well as a p ...

    From $123 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Hot Tub + Bonfires on main Lake Shafer Waterfront
    From $551 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Hot Tub + Bonfires on main Lake Shafer Waterfront

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    10

    Custom-designed lakefront home built for multi-family & multi-generational getaways. • Newly built Main house (2017) • 1 ...

    From $551 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Spacious 5 bdr Lake Shafer house with breathtaking view
    From $655 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Spacious 5 bdr Lake Shafer house with breathtaking view

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    5
    Sleeps:
    10

    With deck overlooking at Gorgeous Lake Shafer Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park – 5 minute walk - Old school iconi ...

    From $655 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • One bedroom cottage - Standard 09
    From $211 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    One bedroom cottage - Standard 09

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    5

    Bungalow cottages are small cottages that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option ...

    From $211 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • 2 bedrooms Cottage -Standard 05
    From $209 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    2 bedrooms Cottage -Standard 05

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    5

    Bungalow cottages are small spaces that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option . ...

    From $209 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • One bedroom cottage -Standard 06
    From $209 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    One bedroom cottage -Standard 06

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    5

    Bungalow cottages are small cottages that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option ...

    From $209 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Two bedrooms Cottage
    From $250 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Two bedrooms Cottage

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Single cottages are a very nice sized 2 bedroom in it's own building. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place for your ...

    From $250 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Studio unit with kitchenette
    From $162 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Studio unit with kitchenette

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    2

    Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and King sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...

    From $162 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Studio unit with kitchenette
    From $158 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Studio unit with kitchenette

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    2

    Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and king sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...

    From $158 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Two bedrooms Cottage
    From $246 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Two bedrooms Cottage

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Single cottages are a very nice sized 2 bedroom in its own individual building (not a duplex). Blue Door Cottages is th ...

    From $246 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Studio unit with kitchenette
    From $158 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Studio unit with kitchenette

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    2

    Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and King sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...

    From $158 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Year Round Lake Home with Wonderful Lake Frontage
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Year Round Lake Home with Wonderful Lake Frontage

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    12

    Year round Lake Shafer Home, three bedrooms (king, full, twin) three bathrooms. Lakefront home just steps from the water ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lakeside Cottage w/ Spacious Multi-level Deck and Outdoor Living Space
    From $277 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Lakeside Cottage w/ Spacious Multi-level Deck and Outdoor Living Space

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    The perfect spot for some family fun or a weekend getaway on Lake Freeman! (Note: We are a completely non-smoking home ...

    From $277 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Home on Lake Shafer with 120 Ft Waterfront
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Home on Lake Shafer with 120 Ft Waterfront

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    9

    Lake front property on Lake Shafer. this home has 120 feet of lake front. great place to swim and dock your boat. Hom ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Charming Riverfront Retreat in Monticello!
    From $320 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Charming Riverfront Retreat in Monticello!

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    7

    Leave the busy life behind and head to this Monticello vacation rental for some relaxation! This 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom ...

    From $320 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Rustic Cabin-Farmhouse Vibe Secluded with Hot Tub
    From $650 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Rustic Cabin-Farmhouse Vibe Secluded with Hot Tub

    Bedrooms:
    4
    Bathrooms:
    8
    Sleeps:
    21

    Completely renovated inside and out in 2022. A Rustic feel in a Country setting. GET AWAY FROM IT ALL. Yet only 15 miles ...

    From $650 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Tranquil Lake Cottage
    From $752 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Tranquil Lake Cottage

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    12

    This beautiful decorated cottage is perfect for a family or group. There is lots of indoor and outdoor seating to enjoy ...

    From $752 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • On Lake Shafer Right Next To Indiana Beach's South Entrance
    From $366 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    On Lake Shafer Right Next To Indiana Beach's South Entrance

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    12

    Rustic Two-Story Lake Cottage that sleeps 10-12 people. Large fenced in front yard and steps to dock on the lake in bac ...

    From $366 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lake Freeman house w/boat dock... Minutes from Indiana Beach/Lake Shafer
    From $318 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Lake Freeman house w/boat dock... Minutes from Indiana Beach/Lake Shafer

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    12

    Surrounded by lush evergreen trees in the front and side of property with seasonal trees and foliage in the backyard tha ...

    From $318 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Lakeside Paradise
    From $875 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Lakeside Paradise

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    16

    Welcome to Lakeside Paradise! This beautiful 4 bedroom, 3 &1/2 bath is located lake front on Lake Freeman. This is the ...

    From $875 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • The Lake House Everyone Wants w/two decks, great amenities & optional Pontoon!
    From $456 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    The Lake House Everyone Wants w/two decks, great amenities & optional Pontoon!

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    10

    Welcome to Turtles on the Wall! A Fun, Laid-Back Lake Getaway on Lake Shafer — Optional Pontoon Available! Freshly up ...

    From $456 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • A peaceful retreat, come relax on Lake Shafer. Fire pit, kayaks & games.
    From $384 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    A peaceful retreat, come relax on Lake Shafer. Fire pit, kayaks & games.

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    10

    Our Lakehouse is directly on Lake Shafer. The house has Central AC and all the modern amenaties. It can host up to 10 ...

    From $384 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Our farmhouse is only 5 miles from Luke Bryan concert venue for September 19!
    From $284 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Our farmhouse is only 5 miles from Luke Bryan concert venue for September 19!

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    6

    Enjoy the quiet country setting, only 25 minutes to Purdue. Our three bedroom two bathroom farmhouse is located right of ...

    From $284 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Charming Cottage on Lake Shafer-optional Pontoon! Screened gazebo and swim deck!
    From $500 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Charming Cottage on Lake Shafer-optional Pontoon! Screened gazebo and swim deck!

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    Attending an event at The Lighthouse B&B and they're all booked up? We're a four minute drive from the venue! *Check o ...

    From $500 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Charming 2-bedroom cottage in peaceful Monticello with AC, WiFi
    From $203 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Charming 2-bedroom cottage in peaceful Monticello with AC, WiFi

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    5

    Lake life is the best life! After staying at the Cozy Cove Cottage, we think you will agree. From enjoying a cup of coff ...

    From $203 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lucretia's Lakeside
    From $372 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Lucretia's Lakeside

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Located in Monon, this adorable house is a dream. With 2 bedrooms featuring a queen bed and a full bed, along with 2 bat ...

    From $372 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Firefly at Lake Shafer
    From $140 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Firefly at Lake Shafer

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    4

    Enjoy lake life in this cozy cottage on Lake Shafer! Plenty of charm throughout with beautiful views, covered porch, din ...

    From $140 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Charming 3-bedroom house in Monticello. Just a short walk to Indiana Beach.
    From $486 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Charming 3-bedroom house in Monticello. Just a short walk to Indiana Beach.

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    8

    Enjoy a peaceful stay at this 3-bedroom house in Monticello. It features 2 queen beds, 1 sofa bed, and 2 twin beds. It’s ...

    From $486 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lake Shafer Home: Fish, Swim, Kayak, BBQ, Sunsets, ten minutes to Indiana Beach
    From $544 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Lake Shafer Home: Fish, Swim, Kayak, BBQ, Sunsets, ten minutes to Indiana Beach

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    13

    Family friendly spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home ON Lake Shafer facing west for amazing sunsets! Several levels of de ...

    From $544 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Lake Shafer Country Cottage with Magnificent View
    From $206 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Lake Shafer Country Cottage with Magnificent View

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    5

    Located 15 minutes outside Monticello on Lake Shafer, this fabulous, historic country cottage offers a cozy retreat for ...

    From $206 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Great Price for 2026! Convenient quiet addition 3-bedroom  Monticello Home
    From $133 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Great Price for 2026! Convenient quiet addition 3-bedroom Monticello Home

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    3
    Sleeps:
    6

    PARKING NOTE!! If you are rejecting this rental due to driveway ADA markings please don't. There is parking at SIDE OF ...

    From $133 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Standard Double with Patio at Indiana Beach Hotel
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Standard Double with Patio at Indiana Beach Hotel

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Ideal for families or small groups, our Standard Double Room offers everything you need for a comfortable and convenient ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • King Room at Indiana Beach Hotel
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    King Room at Indiana Beach Hotel

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    2

    Unwind in this inviting King Room featuring a plush king-size bed with all the essentials for a relaxing stay. The room ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • Family Suite with Patio at Indiana Beach Hotel
    From $133 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Family Suite with Patio at Indiana Beach Hotel

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    5

    Our Family Suite offers everything you need for a comfortable and convenient stay. Each room features its own private en ...

    From $133 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Standard Double Room at Indiana Beach Hotel
    From $133 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Standard Double Room at Indiana Beach Hotel

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Ideal for families or small groups, our Standard Double Room offers everything you need for a comfortable and convenient ...

    From $133 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Relaxing Lakefront Escape on Lake Shafer
    From $266 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Relaxing Lakefront Escape on Lake Shafer

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    5

    Escape to beautiful Lake Shafer and enjoy the perfect lakeside getaway in this cozy 2-bedroom, 1 bath house. Whether you ...

    From $266 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details
  • Fall and Winter at Lake Shafer
    From $710 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Fall and Winter at Lake Shafer

    Bedrooms:
    2
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    12

    There’s something extra special about Lake Shafer in the fall. The summer crowds fade, the lake becomes peaceful, the tr ...

    From $710 per night (USD)

    Expedia

    Details
  • Cabin 3 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Cabin 3 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Cabin 3 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a classic Lake Shafer getaway with comfort, convenience, and an unbeatable locati ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Cabin 2 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Cabin 2 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Cabin 2 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a classic Lake Shafer getaway with comfort, convenience, and an unbeatable locati ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • Motel 9 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Motel 9 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    8

    Motel 9 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a simple yet welcoming Lake Shafer stay with the same great resort amenities as t ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Cabin 4 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Cabin 4 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Cabin 4 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a classic Lake Shafer getaway with comfort, convenience, and an unbeatable locati ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • Cabin 5 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Cabin 5 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Cabin 5 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a classic Lake Shafer getaway with comfort, convenience, and an unbeatable locati ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Motel 8 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Motel 8 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Motel 8 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a simple yet welcoming Lake Shafer stay with the same great resort amenities as t ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • Cabin 1 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Cabin 1 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    2
    Sleeps:
    6

    Cabin 1 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a classic Lake Shafer getaway with comfort, convenience, and an unbeatable locati ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Cabin 6 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Cabin 6 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Cabin 6 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a classic Lake Shafer getaway with comfort, convenience, and an unbeatable locati ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • Motel 11 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Motel 11 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Motel 11 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a simple yet welcoming Lake Shafer stay with the same great resort amenities as ...

    Click For Pricing

    VRBO

    Details
  • Motel 10 at Dockside Lake Resort
    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Motel 10 at Dockside Lake Resort

    Bedrooms:
    1
    Bathrooms:
    1
    Sleeps:
    4

    Motel 10 at Dockside Lake Resort offers a simple yet welcoming Lake Shafer stay with the same great resort amenities as ...

    Click For Pricing

    Expedia

    Details
  • Waterfront on the Tippecanoe River / Lake Freeman
    From $572 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Waterfront on the Tippecanoe River / Lake Freeman

    Bedrooms:
    3
    Bathrooms:
    4
    Sleeps:
    12

    Experience the ultimate waterfront getaway less than 2 hours from Chicago on the Tippecanoe River and Lake Freeman —just ...

    From $572 per night (USD)

    VRBO

    Details