Fire Island, New York Vacation Rentals. Book Beach Rentals, Lake Houses, Condos, Cabins, Villas, and Homes in Fire Island, New York on RentalSaver.com!

Fire Island Rentals

From $665 per night (USD)
VRBO
Designer beach cottage & studio with bikes, outdoor shower, deck - walk to beach
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
12
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simpl ...
From $665 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1646 per night (USD)
Expedia
Designer cottage with amazing view, serene deck & outdoor shower - walk to beach
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Huron Hideaway Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your des ...
From $1646 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1273 per night (USD)
VRBO
Chalet-by-the-Sea
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Beach House in Mint Condition - 1 Master bedroom with king size bed, 1-bedroom with queen size bed, 2 bedrooms each wit ...
From $1273 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $931 per night (USD)
Expedia
Fire Island Beach House
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
House, 3 Bedrooms, 1 Baths, Sleeps 6 Comfortable, bright, perfect location, just four houses away from the beach! This c ...
From $931 per night (USD)
Expedia
Click For Pricing
VRBO
The Beacon
Bedrooms:
5
Bathrooms:
6
Sleeps:
14
New (2020) 3-story beach house w 360 views from Ocean to Bay. Look out its 55 windows, relax on its 8 outdoor decks and ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Click For Pricing
Expedia
Paradise so close to NYC
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
6
This home is a beautifully kept 2-bedroom house, perfect for family or friends. 1 block from the beach and 1 block fro ...
Click For Pricing
Expedia
From $1393 per night (USD)
VRBO
Newly Renovated Luxury Beach House Ocean Bay Park
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Our home features two Master Bedrooms with Queen size beds, and two additional bedrooms; sleeps 10. Perfect set up for t ...
From $1393 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $891 per night (USD)
Expedia
Updated home in great location with spacious living & outdoor features
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Cayuga Escape Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desi ...
From $891 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1022 per night (USD)
VRBO
Spacious beach cottage with private pool, hot tub, outdoor area & amazing suite
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
10
15 Seneca Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desired ...
From $1022 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $782 per night (USD)
Expedia
Spacious Dog-Friendly Home with Renovated Kitchen and Bathrooms
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
11
Baywatch Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desired d ...
From $782 per night (USD)
Expedia
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Airy Wooden Beach House with Big Private Deck, close to Atlantic Ocean Beach or gentler bay swimming.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Large open, high-ceilinged living room surround by four air-conditioned bedrooms, two enclosed porches, large private op ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
$Affordable Ocean Beach, Fire Island Studio Sleeps 2 max, WiFi, 31\ Smart ROKU TV$
From $571 per night (USD)
Expedia
Affordable Ocean Beach, Fire Island Studio Sleeps 2 max, WiFi, 31\" Smart ROKU TV
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
3
Affordable Studio Apartment, Sleeps 2 maximum. 25 and older please. Similar to a large hotel room. Check in 4 PM, Chec ...
From $571 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $810 per night (USD)
VRBO
2025 Ocean Bay Park Booking Now- Beautiful Family Home
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
5
Beautiful Home nestled in the quieter part of Ocean Bay Park Home sleeps 7 Bedroom 1 -king size bed Bedroom 2- 2 twins ...
From $810 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $657 per night (USD)
Expedia
Ocean Beach Getaway
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Enjoy this classic beach house with modern updates in the center of Ocean Beach. Everything you need to enjoy a day at ...
From $657 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $992 per night (USD)
VRBO
Fire Island Home w/ Guest Cottage in Atlantique
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
9
Considered one of Fire Islands Best Kept Secrets, Atlantique is a Laid Back Community w/o the Crowded Beaches, however c ...
From $992 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $394 per night (USD)
Expedia
Spacious home with renovated kitchen, large deck, & tennis
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Wilmot Escape Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desi ...
From $394 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1200 per night (USD)
VRBO
Ocean View Home w/ a Rooftop Sundeck, Free WiFi, Private Pool, & Central A/C
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
Poolside Chic by the Sea Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply ente ...
From $1200 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $881 per night (USD)
Expedia
A slice of paradise 1 block to beach with private pool, 3 decks, modern interior
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
Paradiso Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desired d ...
From $881 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $770 per night (USD)
VRBO
Charming oceanfront home w/ stunning views & wraparound deck - steps from beach
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
7
A Midsummer Night's Dream Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply ent ...
From $770 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1147 per night (USD)
Expedia
Fully renovated 4 bedroom and 2 full bathrooms Sleeps 9
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
9
This is a lovely well maintained family home. We have owned the home for 30 years and we take tremendous pride in the ho ...
From $1147 per night (USD)
Expedia
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Ocean Beach House Labor Day Weekend
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
11
The property is available Labor days weekend for 6 days. The property is located minutes walk from the beach in New Yor ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
From $1065 per night (USD)
Expedia
5th from the beach, dog friendly, sleeps 10, outdoor shower a/c utils included!!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
10
DOG-FRIENDLY RENTAL with all of the amenities and utilities included!! Video walk-thru: https://youtu.be/PhVH8ET5fVw ( ...
From $1065 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $808 per night (USD)
VRBO
Beautiful Beach House with Large Swimming Pool in Ocean Beach
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Centrally located just 5 minutes to beach and downtown Ocean Beach, this house has a true resort feeling, featuring a he ...
From $808 per night (USD)
VRBO
Click For Pricing
Expedia
360 Degree OCEAN and BAY Views! Weekly Summer rentals Sunday to Sunday
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
10
RoundHouse is one back from ocean! Climb up to the roof deck and enjoy sweeping views of all of Fire Island and the bay. ...
Click For Pricing
Expedia
From $669 per night (USD)
VRBO
Ocean Beach Bayview Cottage
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
5
This cozy cottage is located just one house away from the Great South Bay, and it's only a 2-minute walk to the bay swim ...
From $669 per night (USD)
VRBO
Click For Pricing
Expedia
Beach Vacation
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
9
Three houses, off the ocean. Huge deck, grill, bikes, 4 a/c bedrooms, 1.5 indoors baths plus large outdoor shower, dinin ...
Click For Pricing
Expedia
From $1512 per night (USD)
VRBO
CHECK OUT OUR STELLAR REVIEWS-All rental must be for 6 nights 7 day or more
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
This home is in a unique summer beach community on fire island in New York. The area is accessible by passenger ferry o ...
From $1512 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $686 per night (USD)
Expedia
The Raabbit Hole
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
11
This is the perfect place for families and their furry friends. It is located in the heart of ocean beach. Within a 2 mi ...
From $686 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $852 per night (USD)
VRBO
Fair Harbor: 30 Seconds to the Ocean ★★★★★
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
All reservations are WEEKLY. MONDAY to MONDAY. Check-in MONDAYS after 4PM. Check out by MONDAYS 10:00AM. Address: 108 ...
From $852 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $767 per night (USD)
Expedia
Charming Fire Island Retreat
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
You will love our cozy, well-appointed home. Whether it's relaxing on the front screened in porch, sunbathing on the ro ...
From $767 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $905 per night (USD)
VRBO
Beach Cottage on Fire Island
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Steps from the ocean, spacious and recently remodeled home ready for your beach vacation! Casita Del Mar has it all! En ...
From $905 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $885 per night (USD)
Expedia
Fire Island / Ocean Bay Park
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Now accepting 2025 reservations. Original 1960's beach house with updated kitchen and bathrooms. Three bedrooms (king, ...
From $885 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1198 per night (USD)
VRBO
Ocean Therapy-A few steps from the beach
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
See and hear the ocean from this great beach house that just a few steps from the beach with lifeguards. Always being u ...
From $1198 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $414 per night (USD)
Expedia
One Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park with deck & gas grill
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
4
The Surfcomber Unit 1 Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter y ...
From $414 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1135 per night (USD)
VRBO
Charming getaway near the beach w/ free WiFi, gas grill, and partia A/C
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
Seaside Escape on Huron Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter ...
From $1135 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1104 per night (USD)
Expedia
Fire Island Beach House - Atlantique
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Welcome to The Crazy Coconut! Our fully air conditioned home features bayfront views and is 2nd from the bay and a 3 mi ...
From $1104 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1209 per night (USD)
VRBO
Ocean Bay Park Multi-Apartment Home with decks & gas grills
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
18
The Surfcomber Multi-Residence Home Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. ...
From $1209 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $497 per night (USD)
Expedia
2 Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park, walk to beach and entertainment
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
10
The Surfcomber Unit 3 Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter y ...
From $497 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1165 per night (USD)
VRBO
Luxury 3-bedroom Pines house with 360-degree views
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
You'll be renting our charming home in the East end of Fire Island Pines. This house is perfect for groups of up to 6 pe ...
From $1165 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1744 per night (USD)
Expedia
Charming home close to beach with fast WiFi & washer/dryer - dog-friendly
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Pura Vida Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desired ...
From $1744 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1020 per night (USD)
VRBO
Fire Island Beach House
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Ideally located Fire Island beachhouse. Located in the family friendly community of Kismet. Close to the ocean, bay, fer ...
From $1020 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $730 per night (USD)
VRBO
Stay here!-Newly Renovated Beach House (steps to beach)
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
• We rent our home for a 7 day/6 night stay only, Monday to Sunday, with some exceptions, just ask us. • We don't have ...
From $730 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $427 per night (USD)
VRBO
One Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park with Rooftop Deck
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
4
The Surfcomber Unit 2 Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter y ...
From $427 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $862 per night (USD)
VRBO
PINES HUGE SEXY 4 BEDROOM APT-PETS OK!!!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
6
Sleeps:
11
QUICK RESPONSE!!!!! FI PINES BEACH ESCAPE!-!!!!!LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION!!!!! EXACTLY FAR ENOUGH FROM HARBOR FOR PEA ...
From $862 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $559 per night (USD)
VRBO
PINES AMPLE 1 BED APT!-PETS OK
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
QUICK RESPONSE!!!! FI PINES BEACH ESCAPE!-!!!!!LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION!!!!! EXACTLY FAR ENOUGH FROM HARBOR FOR PEAC ...
From $559 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $627 per night (USD)
VRBO
PINES SEXY 3 BEDROOM APT!-PETS OK
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
7
QUICK RESPONSE!!!!! FI PINES BEACH ESCAPE!-!!!!!LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION!!!!! EXACTLY FAR ENOUGH FROM HARBOR FOR PEA ...
From $627 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $975 per night (USD)
VRBO
Large Home with Ocean Views, Fireplace, and Gas Grill - Dogs Welcome
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
6
Sleeps:
10
Robbins Rest Retreat Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter yo ...
From $975 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $790 per night (USD)
Expedia
Bayfront Fun! - 3 BR and 3 Ensuite Bath with Hot Tub!
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Location Location Location! This newly appointed modernist home resides directly on the Bay and is just three blocks eas ...
From $790 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $675 per night (USD)
VRBO
Fair Harbor, Fire Island, NY Magical Place- 700 feet to ocean or bay. Wonderful!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
5
Barrier island beauty- Sunrises, sunsets from ocean to bay. This is a couples or family home. Small pet friendly. (We pr ...
From $675 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $971 per night (USD)
VRBO
Steps to the beach. Live your summer dreams. Pet friendly updated beach cottage.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
Take the ferry to the car free island, Ocean Bay Park and enjoy a family friendly cottage. All of the amenities, newly ...
From $971 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $3599 per night (USD)
VRBO
Fire Island Pines Oceanfront
Bedrooms:
5
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
An exquisite architect-designed private compound situated behind a large dune on the East End of the Pines, the home ble ...
From $3599 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1391 per night (USD)
Expedia
Spacious 5-bedroom house with central air on Fire Island’s wonderful Ocean Beach
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
12
Family-friendly house with everything you need for a great beach vacation. Enjoy grilling and hanging out on the spacio ...
From $1391 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1019 per night (USD)
VRBO
Oceanside Writer’s Retreat, Steps from the Beach
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Unwind in Sayville at this lovely house. Nestled in a serene neighborhood, this marvelous property offers a charming esc ...
From $1019 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1354 per night (USD)
VRBO
Pristine Queen Ensuite walk out to deck & pool - shared Kitchen LR DR Pool
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Consider this villa your home away from home while you visit Fire Island Pines . This superb property features 1 bedroom ...
From $1354 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $2097 per night (USD)
VRBO
Horace Gifford Design - Modernist Gem on Fire Island - Pines
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
RENTALS ARE WEEKLY THURSDAY TO THURSDAY. Escape to this pleasant house in picturesque Fire Island. This charming vacati ...
From $2097 per night (USD)
VRBO
Click For Pricing
Expedia
Spacious 4-bedroom house in superb Fire Island with WiFi, AC
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
6
Get ready to relax in this 4-bedroom house in Fire Island. This delightful property offers everything you need for a won ...
Click For Pricing
Expedia
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Steps from the beach. 5-bedroom house in charming Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
This fantastic house in Ocean Beach offers 5 bedrooms, including 1 full bed and 9 twin beds. With 2 full bathrooms and a ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Click For Pricing
Expedia
Davis Park, pet-friendly 4-bedroom house; AC w/ full views of both Bay and Ocean
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
This open floor plan beach house offers breathtaking views of both the Great South Bay and Atlantic Ocean. 4 bedrooms; k ...
Click For Pricing
Expedia
From $1009 per night (USD)
VRBO
Large Property With Spacious Deck
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Charming two story beach house one half block from town and one and a half blocks from the beach. Ocean Beach is reache ...
From $1009 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1694 per night (USD)
Expedia
Gatsby's - Heated Plunge Pool & Hot Tub in OBP, Sleeps 24, Steps From The Beach
Bedrooms:
5
Bathrooms:
7
Sleeps:
24
One Of The Few Homes That Can Accommodate Your Entire Group of 16 or more! 3 Day Minimum Booking, Reduced Rate For Week ...
From $1694 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $627 per night (USD)
VRBO
5 houses from the beach, and 5 minutes from town -- Ocean Beach 3-BR hideaway
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
With a big outdoor deck, and an oversized living space inside, you'll have a classic Fire Island experience rain or shin ...
From $627 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $311 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel #15, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 15. This charming second-floor wood-paneled room is your perfect ho ...
From $311 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $308 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #18, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 18. This charming second floor room is your perfect home base for a ...
From $308 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $302 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel #19, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 19. This charming ground-floor wood-paneled room is your perfect ho ...
From $302 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $311 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #20, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 20. This charming second-floor room is your perfect home base for a ...
From $311 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $399 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel #12B, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 12B. This charming 2nd floor room with a deck and views of the bay ...
From $399 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $569 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #5, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 5. This charming ground-floor room is your perfect home base for a ...
From $569 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $311 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel #11, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 11. This charming ground-floor cedar-paneled room is your perfect h ...
From $311 per night (USD)
Expedia
Click For Pricing
VRBO
5-bedroom Summer Club Fire Island Ocean Beach Sunset Views Pool Tennis Gym
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
Experience Fire Island Summer Club Adjacent to Ocean Beachlike a local in this 5-bedroom house. With 4 king beds and 1 ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
From $522 per night (USD)
Expedia
Serene Beach Cottage Robbins Rest, Fire Island
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
5
Your peaceful Robbins Rest, Fire Island getaway awaits at this fabulous 2-bedroom plus loft beach cottage. The hamlet i ...
From $522 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $314 per night (USD)
VRBO
Ocean View 2BR Cottage just 100' off the expansive Fire Island ocean beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
With 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, plus day-beds, this home sleeps 6, and offers perfect indoor/outdoor living with wrap-around de ...
From $314 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $542 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel Junior Suite First Floor, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Junior Suite First Floor. These charming first floor, cedar panel, adjo ...
From $542 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1380 per night (USD)
VRBO
Pines Midcentury 3-bedroom house with AC, WiFi in fabulous Fire Island
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Welcome to this charming house in Fire Island. This phenomenal property boasts 3 bedrooms, including 1 queen bed and 2 f ...
From $1380 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1054 per night (USD)
Expedia
Spacious 5-bedroom house, sleeps 11 with AC, WiFi in adorable Ocean Bay Park
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
11
Located in Ocean Bay Park ,right on the bay, enjoy what this 5-bedroom house has to offer. With 1 double bed, 4 twin be ...
From $1054 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $349 per night (USD)
VRBO
Charming 2-Bedroom Cottage in Fire Island Pines with heated pool!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Escape to this marvelous house in gay paradise Fire Island Pines. This cozy retreat features 2 queen bedrooms, 2 bathroo ...
From $349 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $2619 per night (USD)
VRBO
The Dunes -Oceanfront Renovated Home with Direct Beach Access in OBP. Sleeps 16!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
16
Welcome to “The Dunes” your oceanfront oasis in Ocean Bay Park. Sleeps up to 16! 2 Blocks from the ferry, ramp access to ...
From $2619 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1270 per night (USD)
VRBO
2 BR Private Suite w/Private Living Room & Kitchen
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Two bedroom, one bathroom private poolside suite in Fire Island Pines with a large private living room and kitchen. Priv ...
From $1270 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1371 per night (USD)
VRBO
4 BR with bay views in Corneille Estates. Right next to Ocean Beach and quiet!
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
11
Your peaceful beach getaway awaits in Corneille Estates located on Fire Island near the town of Ocean Beach. Corneille ...
From $1371 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1177 per night (USD)
VRBO
Life's at Ease with an Ocean Breeze
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Welcome to your perfect summer escape in the heart of Ocean Beach, Fire Island! This meticulously maintained coastal-the ...
From $1177 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1020 per night (USD)
VRBO
Beach front 2-bedroom - Fire Island Pines - 30 day min. stay
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Get away to one of the worlds most idealic gay beachfront resort towns. There's no place quite like Fire Island Pines a ...
From $1020 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1244 per night (USD)
VRBO
Spacious 4 bedroom home, short walk to beach and town
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
This two story spacious home has open 2nd fl space with large kitchen, den, living area, dining area that opens to 2nd f ...
From $1244 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1503 per night (USD)
VRBO
OCEAN VIEW. 4 bedroom house plus loft in Ocean Beach.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
15
Enjoy this beach house that is just steps from the ocean! It is a 4 bedroom home, with 1 full bath in the rear of the ho ...
From $1503 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $733 per night (USD)
VRBO
Fun and fabulous 3br in Cherry Grove
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Welcome to Haus Flamingo! She's colorful, she has charisma, she will keep your secrets, and make your butt look amazing! ...
From $733 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1182 per night (USD)
VRBO
Oceanfront waves & breezes ~ 4 bed/2 bath in Robbins Rest, Fire Island, NY
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
9
—- Availability usually posts by February for the summer season—-Panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean and the Great Sou ...
From $1182 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1004 per night (USD)
VRBO
Ocean Beach 5 Bedroom Spectacular Home centrally located.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
13
Beautiful five bedroom home nestled in the hearth of Ocean Beach. Short walk to Beach, Ferry, Restaurants and night life ...
From $1004 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $629 per night (USD)
VRBO
Discounted June! LARGE HOME -5 br 2 ba sleeps 12, POOL!! Families Welcome!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
12
WELCOME TO THE NEW MOANA!! WITH POOL 360 Surf Road OUR HOUSE IS NOT LISTED ON CRAIGSLIST NOR DO WE WORK WITH ANY INTE ...
From $629 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $877 per night (USD)
VRBO
4 bdrm on large private beach. AC. Bayfront. Great view and gorgeous new deck!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Enjoy the unique architecture and awesome location of this air conditioned landmark, 4 bedroom 2 bath home with stunning ...
From $877 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $591 per night (USD)
Expedia
OCEAN BEACH, Fire Island, 3 bedroom, close to ferry, village and all beaches!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
watch the virtual tour at https://youtube.com/watch?v=NRmf4pDyr0Q Fire Island is a magical island off the southern co ...
From $591 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1416 per night (USD)
VRBO
Fully Renovated Family Beach House 2022 Dates now available!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
12
This spacious 4 bedroom beach house is perfect for a family getaway. This house is centrally located on a quiet block be ...
From $1416 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1755 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seaview Beach House - Steps to Ocean and Town
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Beautiful bright beach home! Well decorated and very comfortable. Close to all that Fire Island has to offer, ocean, bay ...
From $1755 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $775 per night (USD)
VRBO
Ocean Bay Park Sanctuary - 4th week just opened up with a cancelation!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Hello Soon to be relaxed beach goers! Charming beach house, 4 bedrooms, kitchen, social living room, dining room, and ...
From $775 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1109 per night (USD)
VRBO
Ocean Bay Park - NOW BOOKING 2025 SEASON! SEPTEMBER DATE AVAILABLE
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
15
House, 5 Bedrooms, 3 Bathrooms, (Sleeps 15) with High-Speed Internet To access streaming services, you will need to use ...
From $1109 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1123 per night (USD)
VRBO
OCEAN BEACH - HAPPY PLACE - LARGE BEACH HOUSE - 4br/2bath/3 showers. SLEEPS 11+
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
12
OCEAN BEACH... "The HAPPY PLACE" ....Beautiful Fire Island BEACH HOUSE ! This is our summer Happy Place that we only re ...
From $1123 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $955 per night (USD)
VRBO
Bright and Breezy Beach House in Ocean Bay Park
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
9
Air Conditioned, light, bright, and breezy beach house. Great for entertaining and family friendly. Trex Decking no spli ...
From $955 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $811 per night (USD)
VRBO
The Great Escape at a Great Location!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Welcome to our charming two-story beach house! Our calendar always accurately reflects current availability. We remain ...
From $811 per night (USD)
VRBO
$Charming Cottage Surrounded By English Gardens\nNew Discounted rates!$
From $700 per night (USD)
VRBO
Charming Cottage Surrounded By English Gardens\nNew Discounted rates!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
You will feel right at home here! Lovingly maintained, this house has all amenities: A/C, wi-fi, fireplace, Four comfort ...
From $700 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $859 per night (USD)
VRBO
Making Summer Memories in Ocean Beach, Fire Island at Squid Lips Cabana
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
11
Enjoy your time together in a four-bedroom, two full baths home. Complete with all you need for a fantastic vacation in ...
From $859 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1208 per night (USD)
VRBO
Pet Friendly 4BR 2 bath w/ New Hot Tub and Huge Deck in Ocean Beach near Seaview
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Firefly Landing is a bright, airy beach house nestled in the heart of Ocean Beach, Fire Island—just a five-minute stroll ...
From $1208 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $993 per night (USD)
VRBO
Great Beach Get-A-Way! 4 Bedroom, 1.5 bath
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
11
4 Bedrooms, 1.5 Baths, Outdoor Shower, Renovated Kitchen, Large Deck, WiFi, Smart TV, Laundry, Central A/C Great beach h ...
From $993 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $696 per night (USD)
VRBO
Fire Island Getaway-Weeks/Midweeks/Weekends-100 yards to Beach! FAMILY-FRIENDLY!
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Bright & airy, fully-equipped 3-bedroom house with two decks (one with a huge cedar outdoor shower) and a balcony deck - ...
From $696 per night (USD)
VRBO

Search Your Destination Now!

Fire Island Rentals

Rental Rates ($USD weekly)

Guests

Check Rates & Availability:

Results: 406 Rentals