Fire Island, New York Vacation Rentals. Book Beach Rentals, Lake Houses, Condos, Cabins, Villas, and Homes in Fire Island, New York on RentalSaver.com!

Fire Island Rentals

Filter

Popular Areas

From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #19, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 19. This charming ground-floor wood-paneled room is your perfect ho ...
From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $325 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel #20, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 20. This charming second-floor room is your perfect home base for a ...
From $325 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $407 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #12B, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 12B. This charming 2nd floor room with a deck and views of the bay ...
From $407 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $325 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel #16, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 16. This charming second-floor wood-paneled room is your perfect ho ...
From $325 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $290 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #5, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 5. This charming ground-floor room is your perfect home base for a ...
From $290 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $325 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel #11, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 11. This charming ground-floor cedar-paneled room is your perfect h ...
From $325 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #10, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 10. This charming ground-floor cedar-paneled room is your perfect h ...
From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1474 per night (USD)
VRBO
2 BR Private Suite w/Private Living Room & Kitchen
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Two bedroom, one bathroom private poolside suite in Fire Island Pines with a large private living room and kitchen. Priv ...
From $1474 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #24, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 24. This charming ground-floor cedar-paneled room is your perfect h ...
From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $581 per night (USD)
VRBO
Serene Beach Cottage Robbins Rest, Fire Island
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Your peaceful Robbins Rest, Fire Island getaway awaits at this fabulous 2-bedroom plus loft beach cottage. The hamlet i ...
From $581 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $296 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #12A, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 12A. This charming ground-floor cedar-paneled room is your perfect ...
From $296 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $2228 per night (USD)
VRBO
Dunecrest by RoveTravel - Family Oceanfront with Heated Pool
Bedrooms:
5
Bathrooms:
6
Sleeps:
12
Summary: Welcome to Dunecrest, a Rove Travel Home! Rove offers beautifully designed residences with the quality and car ...
From $2228 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $304 per night (USD)
VRBO
Ocean View 2BR Cottage just 100' off the expansive Fire Island ocean beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
With 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, plus day-beds, this home sleeps 6, and offers perfect indoor/outdoor living with wrap-around de ...
From $304 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $523 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel Junior Suite, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Junior Suite. These charming second-floor adjoining rooms, (21 & 22) are ...
From $523 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #21, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 21. This charming second-floor wood-paneled room is your perfect ho ...
From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $325 per night (USD)
Expedia
Seashore Condo Hotel #22, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 22. This charming second-floor wood and beachy-paneled room is your ...
From $325 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $2040 per night (USD)
VRBO
The Legendary Pyramid House
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Midcentury marvel with forever views over the Fire Island National Seashore. 3 bedrooms, including a large primary suite ...
From $2040 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1646 per night (USD)
VRBO
Incredible New Construction Ocean & Bay View with Pool located in Ocean Bay Park
Bedrooms:
5
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
Entertainer's paradise in Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island! This stunning brand new construction bay view home boasts 5 spaci ...
From $1646 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel #9, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
1
Sleeps:
2
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Unit 9. This charming ground-floor cedar-paneled room is your perfect ho ...
From $325 per night (USD)
VRBO
Click For Pricing
Expedia
Luxury 4 BR, 4.5 bath bay front home in Fire Island Pines with full amenities
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
This 3200 sq ft 4-bedroom home is perfect for your escape to Fire Island that easily sleep 8-10 people. The house is lo ...
Click For Pricing
Expedia
From $521 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel Junior Suite First Floor, Cozy Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to Junior Suite First Floor. These charming first floor, cedar panel, adjo ...
From $521 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1414 per night (USD)
VRBO
Pines Midcentury 3-bedroom house with AC, WiFi in fabulous Fire Island
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Welcome to this charming house in Fire Island. This phenomenal property boasts 3 bedrooms, including 1 queen bed and 2 f ...
From $1414 per night (USD)
VRBO
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Spacious 5-bedroom house, sleeps 11 with AC, WiFi in adorable Ocean Bay Park
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
11
Located in Ocean Bay Park ,right on the bay, enjoy what this 5-bedroom house has to offer. With 1 double bed, 4 twin be ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
From $349 per night (USD)
VRBO
Charming 2-Bedroom Cottage in Fire Island Pines with heated pool!
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Escape to this marvelous house in gay paradise Fire Island Pines. This cozy retreat features 2 queen bedrooms, 2 bathroo ...
From $349 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $159 per night (USD)
VRBO
~Home Comforts, Roku SmartTV, Fast WiFi~
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
8
About this space Enjoy the comforts of home in this first floor, private 2-bedroom condo in the SW Chicago Suburbs. Enjo ...
From $159 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $952 per night (USD)
Expedia
Autism-Ready Family Oasis steps away from the Beach
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Welcome to Spectrum House, your perfect summer getaway designed with the utmost consideration for families with children ...
From $952 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $813 per night (USD)
VRBO
Charming 2-Bedroom Beach Cottage in Ocean Bay Park
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
4
Cozy 2-Bedroom Beach House Steps from the Sand in Ocean Bay Park Welcome to your perfect beach getaway! This charming 2 ...
From $813 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $232 per night (USD)
Expedia
Spacious 4-bedroom, 3 bath house in Ocean Beach with WiFi, AC
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
21
Discover this delightful 4-bedroom gem in Ocean Beach, just a short walk to the beach or downtown. This charming house f ...
From $232 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $670 per night (USD)
VRBO
Seashore Condo Hotel Two Bedroom Suite, Spacious Fire Island Escape, Near Ferry - With Bay Views and Steps from the Beach.
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
6
Located at the Seashore Condo Hotel, escape to the Two Bedroom Suite. This spacious ground-floor room is your perfect h ...
From $670 per night (USD)
VRBO
Click For Pricing
Expedia
Fire Island Gem in Ocean Bay Park
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
Charming Home in Ocean Bay Park - Perfect for Families & Groups Located just a 15-minute walk or a quick bike ride from ...
Click For Pricing
Expedia
From $1061 per night (USD)
VRBO
Spacious 4-bedroom house with WiFi and room-by-room ACs in charming Ocean Beach
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
This is one of the original bungalows of Ocean Beach: a classic, historic beach cottage. Built ~1910, then updated to ad ...
From $1061 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $331 per night (USD)
Expedia
“THE GOOSE” A Charming 2-bedroom bungalow with WiFi and AC in Mastic Beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
6
Welcome to this lovely bungalow in Mastic Beach. Located 1/2 mile (walking distance) from Narrow Bay-Dock and 3 miles fr ...
From $331 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $394 per night (USD)
VRBO
Dahlia by the Bay, walking distance from marina
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
7
Your cozy getaway awaits. for a peaceful time and nature beauty. Enjoy this beautiful home with your family and friends. ...
From $394 per night (USD)
VRBO
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Charming 4-bedroom house with Pool, Chefs Kitchen, WiFi and AC in Davis Park.
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Located in Davis Park, this fabulous house boasts a pool, 4 bedrooms - 2 with queen beds and 2 with twin beds, a fully e ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Relaxing 4-Bedroom Oasis in Ocean Bay Park - Perfect for Families & Friends
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
15
4 Bedrooms 2 Full Bathrooms Fully Equipped Kitchen & Dining Area Bikes Included for Easy Exploring BBQ Grill for Out ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
From $1354 per night (USD)
Expedia
4-Bedroom, Stunning House, Fire Island Pines
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Located in Fire Island, enjoy what this 4-bedroom house has to offer. With 8 twin beds that can become king, 2 bathrooms ...
From $1354 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $835 per night (USD)
VRBO
Charming two story house in beautiful Fair Harbor, Fire Island minutes to beach.
Bedrooms:
1
Bathrooms:
2
Sleeps:
6
Welcome to your summer sanctuary. Situated in the heart of Fair Harbor, one of Fire Island's most charming and sought af ...
From $835 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1871 per night (USD)
Expedia
🍁 Fall into Coastal Luxury at Breakers – Ocean Beach, Fire Island 🍁
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Escape to Fire Island this September and October for a quieter, cozier version of summer — without sacrificing the sun, ...
From $1871 per night (USD)
Expedia
Click For Pricing
VRBO
Quintessential beach home steps from the ocean w/ decks, grill & w/d
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
3
Sleeps:
8
The Pelican's Nest Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your ...
Click For Pricing
VRBO
From $2296 per night (USD)
Expedia
Beach house just steps from the Ocean, in Ocean Beach
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
11
Located in Ocean Beach, enjoy what this brand new, beautifully decorated home with all new top of the line appliances, 1 ...
From $2296 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $647 per night (USD)
VRBO
Shirley Bayfront Getaway – Kayak, Swim & Relax
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
10
Waterfront Fun & Beach Bliss – Bayfront Home w/ Kayaks Welcome to your perfect coastal escape in Shirley, NY! This bayf ...
From $647 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1185 per night (USD)
Expedia
Designer 5 Bedroom, 3.5 bath home. Pool, Hot Tub, Pizza Oven, BBQ, bicycles.
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
5
Sleeps:
10
Authentic Designer Home in Ocean Beach with 5 bedrooms awaits. Sleeps 10 Very Comfortably. This charming stylish home fe ...
From $1185 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $1142 per night (USD)
VRBO
Fire Island Pines - Private Bayside Oasis
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
A private oasis in Fire Island Pines just moments from the harbor. Substantially renovated in 2025. 4 bedrooms, 3 bathr ...
From $1142 per night (USD)
VRBO
From $1861 per night (USD)
Expedia
Luxury 4-bedroom house in Fire Island Pines - AC, bay views, heated pool and spa
Bedrooms:
4
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Luxury home, direct bay views, close to beach, heated pool, jacuzzi, central AC, 3 level sun decks. ** 5 night minimum ...
From $1861 per night (USD)
Expedia
From $847 per night (USD)
VRBO
4Bd 2Ba w/ AC & Heated Pool Fire Island Pines Oasis
Bedrooms:
2
Bathrooms:
4
Sleeps:
8
Welcome to your poolside retreat in the heart of the Pines: - 4 bedrooms (sleep 8) complete with no shared walls, separa ...
From $847 per night (USD)
VRBO

Search Your Destination Now!

Fire Island Rentals

Rental Rates ($USD weekly)

Guests

Check Rates & Availability:

Results: 345 Rentals