Lake Shafer Rentals
From $430 per night (USD)VRBO
Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 10
Beautiful lakefront rental house. 5 bedrooms an office, sleeps up to 10 or more comfortably. Perfect space for entertain ...
From $430 per night (USD)VRBO
From $671 per night (USD)Expedia
NEW modern lake house + apt for 15: HOT TUB, beach, firepit, playground, games!
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 15
BRAND NEW lake house, custom designed for the comfort of large families & groups on vacation. This listing includes the ...
From $671 per night (USD)Expedia
Click For PricingVRBO
Spacious Lakefront House, Walkable to Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
Newly remodeled lake house on Lake Shafer right next to Indiana Beach. Beautiful views of the lake with a dock for swim ...
Click For PricingVRBO
From $291 per night (USD)Expedia
Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 4
‘Cozy Cottage’ | Dog Friendly w/ Fee | 3-Season Room | Gas Grill | Fire Pit Make this 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom Monticello ...
From $291 per night (USD)Expedia
From $326 per night (USD)VRBO
Waterfront Monticello Home w/ Fire Pit & Deck!
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 9
Furnished Gazebo | River Views & Access | Gas Fireplace Relax to the ripple of the Tippecanoe River and savor gorgeous ...
From $326 per night (USD)VRBO
Click For PricingExpedia
Blue Door Cottages
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 8
<p>While you're here, you can enjoy all the comforts of home and more, including free WiFi, a picnic area, and an outdoo ...
Click For PricingExpedia
From $503 per night (USD)VRBO
WOW-modern NEW house on Lake Shafer: Hot tub, beach, firepit, playground, games!
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 10
Visit Piper House to enjoy the lake life, beautiful views, hot tub, beach, dock swimming, private playground, fire pits ...
From $503 per night (USD)VRBO
From $540 per night (USD)Expedia
Spacious 5 bdr Lake Shafer house with breathtaking view
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 5
- Sleeps:
- 10
With deck overlooking at Gorgeous Lake Shafer 😎 Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park – 5 minute walk - Old school ico ...
From $540 per night (USD)Expedia
From $382 per night (USD)VRBO
Lake front house with beautiful views and walking distance to Indiana Beach.
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 12
Beautifully designed lakefront home with large windows overlooking Lake Shafer. Perfect getaway for family & group gathe ...
From $382 per night (USD)VRBO
From $174 per night (USD)VRBO
One bedroom cottage - Standard 09
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 5
Bungalow cottages are small cottages that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option ...
From $174 per night (USD)VRBO
From $170 per night (USD)VRBO
2 bedrooms Cottage -Standard 05
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 5
Bungalow cottages are small spaces that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option . ...
From $170 per night (USD)VRBO
From $200 per night (USD)VRBO
2 bedrooms Cottage - Ensuite Standard
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 6
Single cottage is the full building with 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. It also has a front patio. Blue Door Cottages is th ...
From $200 per night (USD)VRBO
From $174 per night (USD)VRBO
One bedroom cottage - Standard 08
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 5
Bungalow cottages are small cottages that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option ...
From $174 per night (USD)VRBO
From $174 per night (USD)VRBO
One bedroom cottage -Standard 06
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 5
Bungalow cottages are small cottages that live large! One bedroom plus a sleeping alcove make a great affordable option ...
From $174 per night (USD)VRBO
From $205 per night (USD)VRBO
Two bedrooms Cottage
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 6
Single cottages are a very nice sized 2 bedroom in it's own building. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place for your ...
From $205 per night (USD)VRBO
From $283 per night (USD)VRBO
2 bedrooms Cottage perfect for a big group!
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 10
Our largest cottage that is perfect for a big group! 2 queen bedrooms, 2 king bed alcoves, 2 bathrooms and large livin ...
From $283 per night (USD)VRBO
From $132 per night (USD)VRBO
Studio unit with kitchenette
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and King sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...
From $132 per night (USD)VRBO
From $133 per night (USD)VRBO
Studio unit with kitchenette
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and King sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...
From $133 per night (USD)VRBO
From $133 per night (USD)VRBO
Studio unit with kitchenette
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and king sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...
From $133 per night (USD)VRBO
From $205 per night (USD)VRBO
Two bedrooms Cottage
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 6
Single cottages are a very nice sized 2 bedroom in its own individual building (not a duplex). Blue Door Cottages is the ...
From $205 per night (USD)VRBO
From $205 per night (USD)VRBO
Two bedrooms Cottage
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 6
Single cottages are a very nice sized 2 bedroom in its own individual building (not a duplex). Blue Door Cottages is the ...
From $205 per night (USD)VRBO
From $132 per night (USD)VRBO
Studio unit with kitchenette
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 2
Studio unit is the size of a hotel suite with a kitchenette and King sized bed. Blue Door Cottages is the perfect place ...
From $132 per night (USD)VRBO
From $170 per night (USD)VRBO
Cute little Weekend Getaway for 2
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 0
- Sleeps:
- 0
In this room you will find a comfy queen bed, fridge, microwave, sink and bathroom. This is the perfect room for two pe ...
From $170 per night (USD)VRBO
From $246 per night (USD)Expedia
Waterfront Studio on Lake Schaffer, Walking distance to Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 0
- Sleeps:
- 0
You will just love our waterfront room. This room features a private furnished patio on the lake, 32-in HDTV, full kitch ...
From $246 per night (USD)Expedia
From $211 per night (USD)VRBO
Year round Lake home w/wonderful frontage, nice yard w/ fire pit, home theatre
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 12
Year round Lake Shafer Home, 3 bedrooms (king, full, twin) 3 bathrooms. Lakefront home just steps from the water. 120' l ...
From $211 per night (USD)VRBO
From $528 per night (USD)Expedia
Completely updated Suite on the Lake
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 12
In this 1250-square-foot Suite you will find a private furnished patio including an impressive view of the lake, Priv ...
From $528 per night (USD)Expedia
From $608 per night (USD)VRBO
Penthouse on the lake, walking distance from Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 14
The penthouse is a second level 4 bedroom 3 bathroom apartment overlooking the lake. There are 2 pull out couches in the ...
From $608 per night (USD)VRBO
From $224 per night (USD)Expedia
Great 2 Bedroom Family Apt right across from Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 8
Upper level 2-bedroom suite offers a full eat-in kitchen, living room with a sleeper futon, HDTV and walk in shower. ...
From $224 per night (USD)Expedia
From $228 per night (USD)VRBO
Unit 6 on the water 2 queen beds
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
2 queen beds with full kitchen. Right on the water. Walking distance to Indiana Beach and access to the lake. Send the k ...
From $228 per night (USD)VRBO
From $281 per night (USD)Expedia
Newly Remodeled Home on Lake Shafer with 120 Ft Waterfront
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 9
Great newly remodeled lake front property on Lake Shafer. this home has 120 feet of lake front. great place to swim an ...
From $281 per night (USD)Expedia
From $344 per night (USD)VRBO
Beautiful lake house with something for everyone
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 8
This house has amazing views year round! With 3 levels of decks, a fire table, charcoal and gas grill, fire pit, lounge ...
From $344 per night (USD)VRBO
From $261 per night (USD)Expedia
Charming Riverfront Retreat in Monticello!
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 7
Leave the busy life behind and head to this Monticello vacation rental for some relaxation! This 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom ...
From $261 per night (USD)Expedia
From $319 per night (USD)VRBO
On Lake Shafer Right Next To Indiana Beach's South Entrance
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 12
Rustic Two-Story Lake Cottage that sleeps 10-12 people. Large fenced in front yard and steps to dock on the lake in bac ...
From $319 per night (USD)VRBO
From $376 per night (USD)VRBO
Adorable Lake Home on Lake Shafer-optional Pontoon, 2 Decks, great amenities!
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 10
Freshly painted and ready for the new season! Additional upgrades include new KING SIZE BED in the primary, new QUEEN SI ...
From $376 per night (USD)VRBO
From $656 per night (USD)VRBO
NEW boat slip and wave runner ramps. Great home next to IN Beach and Golf Course
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 10
NEW boat slip and wave runner lifts are now available to enjoy Lake Life at the Luse Lodge. It will leave you wanting t ...
From $656 per night (USD)VRBO
From $281 per night (USD)Expedia
Unit #2 RV (Reggae Reef Villa)
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
**Lake Property Luxury with Modern Amenities** Our modern RV retreat, just steps from Indiana Beach Amusement & Water P ...
From $281 per night (USD)Expedia
From $264 per night (USD)VRBO
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #1 RV Retreat Villa
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 3
Lake Property Retreat: Unforgettable Getaway! (1 of 5 units available) Experience a stunning retreat with breathtaking ...
From $264 per night (USD)VRBO
From $344 per night (USD)Expedia
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #4 Cheeseburger in Paradise
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 11
2 Bedrooms: The cozy space offers two bedrooms for your comfort. The first features a queen-sized bed, while the second ...
From $344 per night (USD)Expedia
From $296 per night (USD)VRBO
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #3 Key Lime Cottage
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 5
Experience our Lake Cottage Welcome to your tranquil one-bedroom retreat with a view that dreams are made of. Imagine g ...
From $296 per night (USD)VRBO
From $372 per night (USD)Expedia
Charming Cottage on Lake Shafer-optional Pontoon! Screened gazebo and swim deck!
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
Attending an event at The Lighthouse B&B and they're all booked up? We're a four minute drive from the venue! *Check o ...
From $372 per night (USD)Expedia
From $273 per night (USD)VRBO
Lake View Cottage - 2 Bedroom w\/Kitchenette. Family Friendly!
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 5
Your family will be close to everything when you stay at this centrally located resort. The 400 sq ft cottage is approx ...
From $273 per night (USD)VRBO
From $360 per night (USD)Expedia
Peaceful Waterfront Home - Close To Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
Escape to this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom waterfront house retreat in Monticello, Indiana, offering a serene getaway ...
From $360 per night (USD)Expedia
From $389 per night (USD)VRBO
Key Lime Resorts - Unit #5 - 5 O'Clock Somewhere Lake House
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 10
Discover our cozy two-bedroom bakehouse (5 of 5 units on lake property) just down the street from Indiana Beach, offerin ...
From $389 per night (USD)VRBO
From $336 per night (USD)Expedia
Captain’s Shore: Lake level 3-bedroom cottage, perfect for swimming and fishing
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 6
This Monticello lake level cottage(one of the very few)with some of the best views on the lake, Captain’s Quarters, boas ...
From $336 per night (USD)Expedia
From $205 per night (USD)VRBO
Lakeside Cottages - Cozy cottages nestled in a quiet cove right on Lake Shafer! Located at Paradise Resort, just 4.5 miles north of Outrigger Resort and Indiana Beach Amusement Park. These cottages feature 350 sq ft of space and sleep a max of four (
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
Cozy cottages right on the lake? Yes please! These adorable cottages are nestled in a quiet little cove right on Lake Sh ...
From $205 per night (USD)VRBO
From $229 per night (USD)Expedia
Two Bedroom - Lakeview Cabins - These lovely two-bedroom cabins create the ideal lake life vacation setting! Overlooking Lake Shafer and 1/4 mile away from Indiana Beach Amusement Park. 500 sq ft features two (2) full beds and one (1) futon - sleeps
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 5
There's nothing better than waking up to a breathtaking view on the lake. These lovely two-bedroom cabins create the ide ...
From $229 per night (USD)Expedia
From $413 per night (USD)VRBO
Paradise House - Beautiful 3 bedroom house nestled in a quiet cove on Lake Shafer! Offers 1000 sq ft of living space and will sleep 9. An additional Party Den is available to add-on, featuring a bar area and additional sleeping for 3. Located at Para
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 9
Looking for the summer getaway of your dreams? This gorgeous house is located at Paradise Resort with a view of Lake Sha ...
From $413 per night (USD)VRBO
From $218 per night (USD)Expedia
One Bedroom Cabin - Lakeview - Charming 500 sq ft one-bedroom cabin located at Outrigger Resort, just 1/4 mile from Indiana Beach Amustment Park! Features a lake view, private bathroom, kitchen, and living room. One (1) queen bed and one (1) futon al
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
Stay in a one-bedroom cabin located at Outrigger Resort, just 1/4 mile from Indiana Beach Amusement Park and kick your g ...
From $218 per night (USD)Expedia
From $261 per night (USD)VRBO
Two Bedroom Cabin - Street & Pool View - Two bedroom cabin conveniently located at Outrigger Resort, right down the road from Indiana Beach Amusement Park! This 600 sq ft classic cabin offers two (2) queen beds and two (2) futons to sleep six (6)! Am
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 8
Planning a summer getaway with the whole family? This classic cabin located at Outrigger Resort sleeps eight (8) with tw ...
From $261 per night (USD)VRBO
From $324 per night (USD)Expedia
Two Bedroom Cabin - \"The Big One\" - This spacious cabin gets it's name honestly! Cabin is 800 sq ft with two-bedrooms feature three (3) queen beds, one (1) full size bed, and two (2) futons allow for a max of twelve (12) people. Conveniently located
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 12
The Big One doesn't get it's name for its modesty. This cabin is as spacious as they come with 800 sq ft! Two-bedrooms o ...
From $324 per night (USD)Expedia
From $188 per night (USD)VRBO
Studio Cabins - Delightful studio cabins located at Outrigger Resort sleep 4! 1/4 mile away from Indiana Beach Amusement Park. These cabins have options featuring two (2) queen beds OR one (1) queen and one (1) futon. 350-450 square feet. All studio
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 1
- Sleeps:
- 4
These delightful studio cabins are just right for the family on the go! Drop your stuff and get your vacation started wi ...
From $188 per night (USD)VRBO
From $576 per night (USD)Expedia
Fishy Cottage 3 BR 2 BA with Dock on Lake Shafer
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 11
The Fishy Cottage - Monticello, Indiana Our spacious and well-equipped 3 bedroom 2 bath home features stunning lake vie ...
From $576 per night (USD)Expedia
From $297 per night (USD)VRBO
Charming 3-bedroom house in Monticello. Just a short walk to Indiana Beach.
- Bedrooms:
- 2
- Bathrooms:
- 3
- Sleeps:
- 8
Enjoy a peaceful stay at this 3-bedroom house in Monticello. It features 2 queen beds, 1 sofa bed, and 2 twin beds. It’s ...
From $297 per night (USD)VRBO
From $493 per night (USD)Expedia
Waterfront 2BR Cottage: Fire Pit, Grill & Dock -Boat Slip Available additional
- Bedrooms:
- 1
- Bathrooms:
- 2
- Sleeps:
- 7
Booking calendar is not accurate. Please message me to schedule your stay. • Located in scenic Monticello, Indiana – ...
From $493 per night (USD)Expedia
- From $448 per night (USD)
VRBO
Lake Shafer Home: Boat, Swim, Kayak, BBQ, Sunsets, ten minutes to Indiana Beach
- Bedrooms:
- 3
- Bathrooms:
- 4
- Sleeps:
- 13
Spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home ON Lake Shafer facing west for amazing sunsets! Several levels of decking offer gril ...
From $448 per night (USD)VRBO